Budapest Post

Cum Deo pro Patria et Libertate
Budapest, Europe and world news

After slapping down top EU court, Poland asks for its help

After slapping down top EU court, Poland asks for its help

Warsaw and Budapest ask Court of Justice to kill measure that links EU funding to rule of law.
The Polish government took its pick-and-mix approach to EU law to a new level on Monday — asking the bloc’s top court for help just days after rejecting its jurisdiction in key areas.

Poland, along with Hungary, asked the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) to strike down a new measure that allows the EU to cut off funds from the bloc’s budget to countries considered to be breaching the rule of law.

In a years-long battle over core values, EU institutions have accused both Warsaw and Budapest of backsliding on the rule of law and basic democratic standards. Monday’s hearing in Luxembourg, before a panel of red-robed judges in the court’s imposing Grand Chamber, opened a new front in that conflict.

The new measure, passed in December last year, would not allow the EU to stop funds simply due to general concerns about the rule of law. But it would allow the bloc to act over rule-of-law shortcomings that affect the sound management of the budget or the EU’s financial interests — for example, if national courts were not considered to be independent.

That has raised alarm bells in Warsaw and Budapest, where governments fear they could lose out on millions of EU cohesion funds and other economic development cash. Officials expect the European Commission to trigger the measure for the first time in the coming weeks, although it’s unclear which countries will be targeted.

And so, just a few days after the Polish Constitutional Tribunal — backed by the government — ruled that the CJEU had no power to intervene on the country’s controversial judicial reforms, lawyers for the Polish and Hungarian governments asked the very same court to come to their aid.

The lawyers argued that the measure — sometimes known as the “rule-of-law conditionality mechanism” — was not intended to protect the EU budget but to administer a political punishment.

“It’s not a conditionality regime, it’s a mechanism to impose a sanction,” said Sylwia Żyrek, a lawyer representing the Polish government.

Miklós Zoltán Fehér, a senior official from the Hungarian Ministry of Justice, told the court that the measure was a “political procedure with the political intent.”

The two lawyers also argued that the measure was a back-door attempt to apply the so-called Article 7 procedure, under which member countries can be stripped of voting rights inside the EU if they are found to have breached core values. Both Poland and Hungary have been the subject of such proceedings for years but other member states haven’t been able to agree on a conclusion.

At Monday’s hearing, both countries also argued that the rule-of-law provisions in the new measure aren’t sufficiently defined and that the mechanism does not give certainty and clarity for member states.

But lawyers for the Commission, the Council of the EU, the European Parliament and 10 member countries — including Germany, France, the Netherlands, Denmark and Ireland — lined up to defend the measure.

“A breach of the rule of law in a member state clearly poses a risk to the implementation of the EU budget,” argued Tamas Lukacs, a lawyer for the European Parliament.

He also rejected the accusations that the new mechanism is a substitute for the Article 7 procedure. “The two procedures have different objectives,” he said, stressing that the mechanism doesn’t have “punitive or retaliatory” character.

Lawyers for other EU institutions made similar arguments.

The measure formally came into effect in January. But, under a compromise deal late last year, EU leaders asked the European Commission to refrain from implementing it pending any challenge in the Court of Justice.

Members of the European Parliament, however, have put significant pressure on the Commission to trigger the mechanism, going as far as threatening legal action.

The judgment is not expected for several months.
AI Disclaimer: An advanced artificial intelligence (AI) system generated the content of this page on its own. This innovative technology conducts extensive research from a variety of reliable sources, performs rigorous fact-checking and verification, cleans up and balances biased or manipulated content, and presents a minimal factual summary that is just enough yet essential for you to function as an informed and educated citizen. Please keep in mind, however, that this system is an evolving technology, and as a result, the article may contain accidental inaccuracies or errors. We urge you to help us improve our site by reporting any inaccuracies you find using the "Contact Us" link at the bottom of this page. Your helpful feedback helps us improve our system and deliver more precise content. When you find an article of interest here, please look for the full and extensive coverage of this topic in traditional news sources, as they are written by professional journalists that we try to support, not replace. We appreciate your understanding and assistance.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
Russia’s A7 Builds a State-Linked Payments Network Beyond Western Sanctions
AI’s Next Bottleneck Is Power, Not Just Nvidia Chips
Meta Raises AI Spending Target to as Much as $145bn Despite Pressure Over Returns
Danube Drought Exposes Nazi Wrecks and Pushes Central Europe’s Power System to the Brink
Joe Biden’s Cancer Has Spread Beyond His Bones, Hunter Biden Says
Why 2027 Could Be a Strong Year for Stocks—and Why the Forecast Is Fragile
Why Markets May Look Quiet in August After Big Tech Earnings
UK Drought Cuts Harvests and Raises Food-Security Fears
UFO: Pentagon Releases Video of Unidentified Object Tracked Over Middle East
Ukraine Tells Senate Republicans Its Drone War Offers a Blueprint for America
Weight-Loss Drug Boom Tests the Limits of Prescription Advertising Rules
Senate Scrutinises AI-Driven Personalised Pricing
Spain Seeks Mainland Transfers for 1,100 Children Stranded in Ceuta
Spain and Morocco Trade Blame After 72,000 Migrants Enter Ceuta
AI Is Remaking the US Economy, From GDP Growth to iPhone Prices
Europe’s Heat and Drought Are Now Disrupting Power, Shipping and Tourism
Europe’s Drying Rivers Trigger Power Cuts, Factory Shutdowns and Wildfire Emergencies
Record-Low Danube Forces Nuclear Cuts and Emergency Power Curbs
Danube Drought Forces Hungary’s Paks Nuclear Plant Into Full Shutdown
Ceuta Death Toll Rises as Spain and Europe Clash Over Border Response
Valued at $109 Million: F-35B Fighter Jet Crashes in Southern California
Record-Low Danube Exposes Probable Mammoth Remains in Bulgaria
US Says It Has Carried Out Heavy Strikes on Iran After Attempted Attacks on Its Forces
The AI User Nightmare: Private Claude Conversations Leaked to the Internet
Over 24 Hours in the Air: Qantas Airbus Completes Record-Breaking Test Flight
Massive Wildfires Ravage Southern Europe: Fatalities in Greece and Evacuations Across France, Spain, and Turkey
Nvidia Reportedly Takes Vast Texas Data-Centre Lease to Underwrite AI Expansion
FIFA’s Private-Investment Plan for World Cup Rights Draws European Revolt
Apple Briefly Crosses Five Trillion Dollar Valuation as Investors Retreat From AI Bets
Fresh Heatwave Threatens to Rekindle France’s Historic Wildfire Crisis
Following OpenAI's Cyberattack: 'Most Companies Still Do Not Understand What Is Coming'
OpenAI Sued After ChatGPT Allegedly Discouraged Emergency Care Before Near-Fatal Embolism
Miliband Sets Climate and International Law at Centre of UK Diplomacy
Czech Central Bank Governor Rejects Early Euro Entry and Rate-Cut Pressure
Trump Readies New Tariffs as Temporary Global Levy Nears Expiry
Vivienne Westwood Casts Cicciolina, 74, in Its New Autumn Campaign
Dejavu: Germany’s Military Expansion Reshapes Europe’s Strategic Balance With France
Morgan Stanley Builds a Wall Street Lead in AI Infrastructure Finance
High Prices Push Coffee Drinkers Toward Whole Beans and Home Brewing
Trump Draws Boos and Podium Scrutiny at Spain’s World Cup Triumph
Brilliant move: Péter Magyar Moves to Nominate Chess Grandmaster Judit Polgár as Hungary’s President
Spain Defeats Argentina in Extra Time to Win Second World Cup
Current AI Seeks to Build an Open Global AI Infrastructure Outside Big Tech Control
Germany’s Economic Malaise Reopens the Sunday Shopping Debate
Proposed U.S.-Saudi Nuclear Pact Could Permit Limited Uranium Enrichment Under International Safeguards
Netherlands Declares Water Shortage Emergency After Drought Pushes Rivers to Historic Lows
Why Kentucky Fried Chicken Became KFC—and Why the False Explanations Persist
Ukrainian Drones Strike Wildberries Warehouses Deep Inside Russia
Reported CIA Mission Helped Clear the UAE’s Path to Advanced US AI Chips
Artificial Intelligence Capital Fuels Markets While Governments and Regulators Face Mounting Strategic Tests
×