Budapest Post

Cum Deo pro Patria et Libertate
Budapest, Europe and world news

EU leaders ask Poland to respect EU law primacy after defiant ruling

EU leaders ask Poland to respect EU law primacy after defiant ruling

EU leaders have asked Poland to abide by the same rules and legal principles as any of the other members of the European Union do.
The public rebukes, made in the lead-up to a European summit in Brussels, follow an extraordinary ruling by the Polish Constitutional Court earlier this month that openly defied the primacy of EU law, one of the bloc's cornerstone and long-standing principles.

"I do believe Poland has gone too far," said Irish Prime Minister Micheál Martin ahead of the meeting.

"The Polish judicial decision is very far-reaching and doesn’t compare in any shape or form with any previous decisions by national courts, either in breadth or in content. So assertions by the Polish Prime Minister that it’s just another [verdict] in a series of pieces, it doesn’t stack up."

The Taoiseach added the verdict was a "slap in the face" to those member states who are net contributors of the bloc's multi-million budget. All EU countries contribute to the budget, but, in order to redistribute wealth, some give more than what they get, while others get more than what they give.

Poland is the biggest recipient of EU funds, having received more than €18 billion in 2020. Martin also said that the Irish people expect other EU countries to adhere to the bloc's common rules, which "we've all signed up to".

His words were echoed by the leaders of the Benelux (Belgium, the Netherlands and Luxembourg), who all hail from liberal parties and are often the most vocal against instances of democratic backsliding.

The Benelux successfully managed to include a discussion on rule of law in October's European summit, whose original agenda didn't include any item of that sort and was mostly focused on Europe's energy crisis, migration and foreign affairs.

"If we accept that, in fact, Europe is a national interpretation of my personal wishes, that's not the goal. And we accepted to be member states, and we have rules, so we have to respect them," said Luxembourg's Prime Minister Xavier Bettel.

Bettel referred to previous judgments by the EU's Court of Justice (ECJ), whose competence Poland disputes, that found serious deficiencies in the independence of the Polish judiciary.

In recent months, the ECJ has asked Warsaw to dismantle a controversial disciplinary chamber set up by the government to punish judges according to the content of their ruling.

The European Court of Human Rights, a non-EU body, has said that at least one member of the Polish Constitutional Court was unlawfully appointed.

"There’s a decision that the justice system in Poland is not independent, so to get lessons from there is a bit tricky," Bettel said.

"If we accept that European laws are not the same everywhere, this could also mean that European citizens have fewer rights than other European citizens."

Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte said that as long concerns remain over the independence of Poland's judicial system, the EU should not greenlight the €36-billion recovery plan that Warsaw has requested as part of the bloc's €750-billion coronavirus fund.

The Commission has been assessing the plan for the last few months and has repeatedly extended the deadline to publish its assessment.

"We have to be tough but the question is how to get there. My argument would be that the independence of the Polish judiciary is the key issue that we have to discuss and we have to settle," he said, asking his fellow member of the European Council to step up their work.

"This has to do with the foundations of our democracies in this part of the world, so we cannot negotiate."

Alexander De Croo, the Belgian prime minister, regretted the current state of affairs and asked for dialogue to resolve the situation.

"It’s unfortunate that we need to have this discussion because this takes away a lot of bandwidth. We could be spending that time on a discussion about energy prices or the future of the European economy," De Croo told Euronews.

"But this touches at the core of the European project [which is] that any citizen and SME has the exact same rights in Belgium, in Poland or any other European country. This is the core of the European project, it has brought so much prosperity to Belgium but also so much to our Polish friends."

Earlier this week, the European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, who is also a member of the European Council, vowed to use her executive powers to uphold EU values.

"This ruling calls into question the foundations of the European Union. It is a direct challenge to the unity of the European legal order. Only a common legal order provides equal rights, legal certainty, mutual trust between member states and therefore common policies," she told MEPs in Strasbourg.

Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki, who faced off von der Leyen during the plenary session, struck a more conciliatory tone before entering the high-level summit.

"We are ready for dialogue," he said, according to a translation by the Associated Press. "We will of course talk about how to resolve the current disputes in agreement and in dialogue."

Hungary's leader Viktor Orbán came to his defense and openly recognized that Budapest and Warsaw had made an alliance to defend what they see as the unlawful expansion of EU powers.

"Poland [is] the best country in Europe. There is no need to have any sanctions. It's ridiculous," said Orbán, referring to a new conditionality mechanism that can freeze EU funds for countries suspected of breaching EU law.

The Commission is considering triggering the never-used scheme, although its bureaucratic process could be complex and take up to nine months to complete.

"The primacy of the EU law is not in the treaty at all. So the EU has primacy over where it has competences," he said.

"What's going on here is that, regularly, European institutions circumvent the rights of national parliaments and governments and modify the treaties without having any legitimate authority to do so. So the Polish are right."

Despite being one of the union's essential principles, primacy of EU law is not enshrined in any article of the treaties, besides a brief declaration annexed to the texts.

The principle predates the current treaties and dates back to 1964 case Costa v ENEL, when the EU's Court of Justice ruled that, whenever there is a conflict between national law and EU law, the bloc's legislation must prevail. Otherwise, common policies would be unworkable, the tribunal noted.

Over time, the principle evolved and became a consolidated part of the ECJ's jurisprudence, which candidate countries must accept in its totality before joining the European Union.

Primacy only applies in cases where national states have ceded competences to the institutions.

In its majority ruling, the Polish Constitutional Court directly challenged the legal doctrine by rejecting two key articles of the EU treaties: Article 1, which establishes the conferral of competences, and Article 19, which sets up the ECJ's powers.

It is still unclear what sort of ramifications the unprecedented verdict will have in practice for Polish citizens and for the country's judicial cooperation with other member states.

EU leaders hope a solution can be achieved through political dialogue rather than financial pressure, as the European Parliament is demanding. Given the magnitude of the verdict, Warsaw would have to make considerable concessions to appease Brussels.

"We are firm on the principles of rule of law. We think that we have tools, legal tools, institutional tools that we should use," said European Council President Charles Michel before entering the summit.

"But we think also that we must be committed to the dialogue in order to be able to deliver."
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
Unelected PM of the UK holds an emergency meeting because a candidate got voted in… which he says is a threat to democracy…
Farmers break through police barriers in Brussels.
Ukraine Arrests Father-Son Duo In Lockbit Cybercrime Bust
US Offers $15 Million For Info On Leaders Of Cybercrime Group Lockbit
Apple warns against drying iPhones with rice
Alexei Navalny: UK sanctions Russian prison chiefs after activist's death
German economy is in 'troubled waters' - ministry
In a recent High Court hearing, the U.S. argued that Julian Assange endangered lives by releasing classified information.
Tucker Carlson says Boris Johnson wants "a million dollars, in Bitcoin or cash, from Tucker Carlson to talk about Ukraine.
Russia is rebuilding capacity to destabilize European countries, new UK report warns
EU Commission wants anti-drone defenses at Brussels HQ
Von der Leyen’s 2nd-term pitch: More military might, less climate talk
EU Investigates TikTok for Child Safety Concerns
EU Launches Probe Into TikTok Over Child Protection Under Digital Content Law
EU and UK Announce Joint Effort on Migration
Ministers Confirm Proposal to Prohibit Mobile Phone Usage in English Schools
Avdiivka - Symbol Of Ukrainian Resistance Now In Control Of Russian Troops
"Historic Step": Zelensky Signs Security Pact With Germany
"Historic Step": Zelensky Signs Security Pact With Germany
Russian opposition leader Alexey Navalny has died at the Arctic prison colony
Tucker Carlson grocery shopping in Russia. This is so interesting.
France and Germany Struggle to Align on European Defense Strategy
‘A lot higher than we expected’: Russian arms production worries Europe’s war planners
Greece Legalizes Same-Sex Marriage and Adoption Rights
Russia "Very Close" To Creating Cancer Vaccines, Says Vladimir Putin
Hungarian Foreign Minister: Europeans will lose Europe, the Union's policy must change drastically
Microsoft says it caught hackers from China, Russia and Iran using its AI tools
US Rejects Putin's Ceasefire Offer in Ukraine
The Dangers of Wildfire Smoke and Self-Protection Strategies
A Londoner has been arrested for expressing his Christian beliefs.
Chinese Women Favor AI Boyfriends Over Humans
Greece must address role in migrant vessel disaster that killed 600: Amnesty
Google pledges 25 million euros to boost AI skills in Europe
Hungarian President Katalin Novák Steps Down Amid Pardon Controversy
Activist crashes Hillary Clinton's speech, calls her a 'war criminal.'
In El Salvador, the 'Trump of Latin America' stuns the world with a speech slamming woke policing after winning a landslide election
Trudeau reacts to Putin's mention of Canadian Parliament applauding a former Ukrainian Nazi in his interview with Tucker Carlson.
The Spanish police blocked the farmers protest. So the farmers went out and moved the police car out of the way.
Volodymyr Zelenskiy fires top Ukraine army commander
Tucker Carlson's interview with Vladimir Putin raises EU concerns
Finnish Airline, Finnair, is voluntarily weighing passengers to better estimate flight cargo weight
Russia's Economy Expands by 3.6% Due to Increased Military Spending
Ukraine MPs Vote To Permit Use Of Dead Soldiers' Sperm
German Princess Becomes First Aristocrat To Pose Naked On Playboy Cover
UK’s King Charles III diagnosed with cancer
EU's Ursula von der Leyen Confronts Farmer Protests Amid Land Policy Debates
Distinguishing Between Harmful AI Media and Positive AI-Generated Content: A Crucial Challenge for the EU
Tucker Carlson explains why he interviewed Putin
Dutch farmers are still protesting in the Netherlands against the government, following the World Economic Forum's call for 'owning nothing.'
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán stands up for European farmers and says, 'Brussels is suffocating European farmers.
×