Budapest Post

Cum Deo pro Patria et Libertate
Budapest, Europe and world news

Meta: Facebook owner fined €1.2 billion for mishandling data

Meta: Facebook owner fined €1.2 billion for mishandling data

Facebook’s owner, Meta, has been fined €1.2 billion (£1 billion) for mishandling people’s data when transferring it between Europe and the United States.
Issued by Ireland’s Data Protection Commission (DPC), it is the largest fine imposed under the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation privacy law.

GDPR sets out rules companies must follow to transfer user data outside of the EU. Meta says it will appeal against the “unjustified and unnecessary” ruling.

At the crux of this decision is the use of standard contractual clauses (SCCs) to move European Union data to the US.

These legal contracts, prepared by the European Commission, contain safeguards to ensure personal data continues to be protected when transferred outside Europe.

But there are concerns these data flows still expose Europeans to the US’s weaker privacy laws — and US intelligence could access the data.

This decision does not affect Facebook in the UK. The Information Commissioner’s Office told the BBC that the decision “does not apply in the UK” but said it had “noted the decision and will review the details in due course”.

Most large companies have complex webs of data transfers - which can include email addresses, phone numbers and financial information - to overseas recipients, many of which depend on SCCs.

And Meta says their broad use makes the fine unfair.

Facebook President Nick Clegg said: “We are therefore disappointed to have been singled out when using the same legal mechanism as thousands of other companies looking to provide services in Europe.

“This decision is flawed, unjustified and sets a dangerous precedent for the countless other companies transferring data between the EU and US.”

But privacy groups have welcomed that precedent.

Caitlin Fennessy, of the International Association of Privacy Professionals, said: “The size of this record-breaking fine is matched by the significance of the signal it sends.

“Today’s decision signals that companies have a whole lot of risk on the table.”

It could make EU companies demand US partners stored data within Europe - or switch to domestic alternatives, she added.

In 2013, former US National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden disclosed American authorities had repeatedly accessed people’s information via technology companies such as Facebook and Google.

And Austrian privacy campaigner Max Schrems filed a legal challenge against Facebook for failing to protect his privacy rights, setting off a decade-long battle over the legality of moving EU data to the US.

Europe’s highest court, the European Court of Justice (ECJ), has repeatedly said Washington has insufficient checks in place to protect Europeans’ information.

And in 2020, the ECJ, ruled an EU-to-US data transfer agreement invalid.

But the ECJ left the door open for companies to use SCCs, saying the transfer of data to any other third country was valid as long as it ensured an “adequate level of data protection”.

It is that test Meta has been found to have failed.

Asked about the €1.2 billion fine, Schrems said he was “happy to see this decision after 10 years of litigation” but it could have been much higher.

“Unless US surveillance laws get fixed, Meta will have to fundamentally restructure its systems,” he added.

Despite the record-breaking size of the fine, experts have said they think Meta’s privacy practices will not change.

“A billion-euro parking ticket is of no consequence to a company that earns many more billions by parking illegally,” Johnny Ryan, a senior fellow at the Irish Council for Civil Liberties.

The US recently updated its internal legal protections to give the EU greater assurances American intelligence agencies would follow new rules governing such data access.

In 2021, Amazon was fined for similarly flouting the EU’s privacy standard.

Ireland’s DPC has also fined WhatsApp, another Meta-owned business, for breaching stringent regulations relating to the transparency of data shared with its other subsidiaries.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
Hungary's Balancing Act: Boosting Influence While Managing Economic Stability and Political Controversies
Failing the Test of Leadership: Netanyahu's Security Missteps
Pope Francis' Call for Compassion: Balancing Humanitarian Needs with Socio-Economic Realities
Pozitív Fordulatok és Új Lehetőségek: Oktatás, Gasztronómia és Sport Magyarországon
Magyarország szerepe az uniós szankciók kérdésében: Az energetikai stabilitás és az EU egységének egyensúlya
Romanian Authorities Thwart Armed Mercenary Plot, Drawing Parallels to U.S. Capitol Riot
Strategic Explosions: The Volatile Intersection of Guerrilla Tactics and Geopolitics in Ukraine
Austria's Dilemma: Repatriation of Syrian Refugees Amidst Fragile Peace
The Rising Tide of Aridity: Unmasking a Global Threat
Polarization: The Word That Unites a Divided Era
The TikTok Conundrum: A Battle for Free Speech and Innovation
A Test of Balance: Self-Defense and Judicial Equity in Germany
The Compass of Time: Unraveling the 2024 Person of the Year
Swift's Epoch: Revolutionizing Concert History with the Eras Tour
Storm Darragh Ravages the UK: A Pre-Christmas Tempest of Destruction
Enduring Peace or Strategic Uncertainty: Zelensky's Bold Plea Amidst Ukraine's Woes
Notre-Dame Rises Again: A Symbol of Resilience Amidst Turbulent Times
UAE Invests in Quantum Leap: A Bold Move Towards a Trillion-Dollar Future
Dutch Parliament's Controversial Motion Ignites Nationwide Protests
Integration or Intrusion? The Dutch Debate Over Migration Data
Bananas and Cocaine: The Unseen Paths of a Global Epidemic
The Surveillance Mirage: When Millions of Cameras Fail to Deliver Justice
Navigating the Digital Storm: Taylor Swift's Diplomatic Dance in Celebrity Showdowns
Justice Denied: Outrage in Germany as Legal System Fails Rape Victim
Storm Darragh's Menace: UK Prepares with Rare Emergency Alert
Guardians of Safety: Balancing Security and Freedom in Modern Europe
Germany Averts Christmas Market Terror Attack Amid European Political Turmoil
The European Energy Conundrum: Navigating Dependency and Independence
France at a Crossroads: Navigating Political Tumult and Economic Divergence
Britain Leads Charge in AI Safety Amid Global Challenges
A Conflict Beyond Borders: Navigating the Complexities of Israel and Gaza
Georgia's EU Saga: Aspirations, Challenges, and a Nation Divided
Macron's Gamble: Navigating France's Political Tempest
Macron Faces Political Upheaval Amidst France's Government Collapse
Addressing the Human Toll: Europe's Struggle Against Human Trafficking
Georgia's Democratic Challenge: Balancing Between Europe and Sovereignty
Major Events Unfold Worldwide: From New York Tragedy to Californian Quake Relief
A Name’s Ascent: Muhammad Tops Baby Name Charts in England and Wales
Nepal Embraces China's Belt and Road Initiative: A New Geopolitical Battleground?
Georgia's Political Turmoil: A Nation Divided Amid Opposition Crackdowns
Bitcoin's Historic Leap: A New Era or Just Another Bubble?
Nissan’s Challenge: Preserving a Legacy in the Age of Electric Vehicles
South Korea's Democracy Tested: President Yoon’s Martial Law Reversal Sparks Political Reckoning
China Restricts Export of Key Minerals to the US Amid Trade Tensions
Seoul in Crisis: Yoon Suk Yeol's Martial Law Blunder Triggers Political Upheaval
South Korean President Lifts Martial Law After Parliamentary Intervention
Generative AI's Limited Impact on Elections Highlighted by Meta
Ukrainian Soldiers Endure Exhaustion Amid Kursk Conflict
France at the Precipice: Barnier’s Government Confronts an Unprecedented No-Confidence Vote
French Prime Minister Confident of Overcoming No Confidence Vote
×