Budapest Post

Cum Deo pro Patria et Libertate
Budapest, Europe and world news

Why Europe can’t protect itself against Russian sabotage threat

Why Europe can’t protect itself against Russian sabotage threat

Suspected Russian sabotage of Europe’s gas pipelines has officials wondering what infrastructure might be next — and how to protect it.

A startling undersea attack on Europe’s gas pipelines has officials deliberating how to better defend a vast array of local targets that are, effectively, not fully defensible.

For months, European governments have been scouring their military arsenals to help furnish a grueling ground war in Ukraine while making pledges to boost their own defenses. But this week, saboteurs — which many allege were Russian — reminded Europeans that the threat is also closer to home, in the nebulous world of “hybrid” attacks targeting everything from energy systems to internet cables to financial markets and water supplies.

Such assaults lie in the gray zone between war and peace — cloaked in a veneer of deniability and hitting targets that don’t always automatically trigger a military response.

That was the case with the recent explosions on the Nord Stream pipelines connecting Russia and Europe. Some of the infrastructure is jointly Russian- and European-owned, and the attacks occurred in the vague “exclusive economic zones” off the coasts of Denmark and Sweden.

The muddled responsibility makes it difficult to craft a specific reaction — for this incident or others. According to military specialists, possible options on the table are: heightened surveillance, more visible patrolling, ensuring systems have backups and better-coordinated responses. Norway, Denmark and Finland have all already taken a few of these steps.

The ability to swiftly update existing defense plans could dictate whether Europe is fully prepared for another, more serious, assault. And the stakes are only growing as the temperature drops, making basic functions like heat and electricity even more important.

“NATO has [a] quite elaborate policy on hybrid threats and critical infrastructure,” said Edgars Rinkēvičs, Latvia’s foreign minister.

“We now,” he added in a text message, “need to understand if it is up to date.”

A senior diplomat from an eastern NATO country echoed the point: “Since the invasion against Ukraine, all eyes were focused on the revived conventional war in the 21st century, neglecting somehow the importance of preparedness in the field of hybrid tactics.”

And, he added, this sabotage illustrates NATO’s need to keep “developing its defense on all dimensions and across all areas of responsibility.”


A deterrence game


While investigations into the leaks are ongoing, NATO’s northern members and partners have already begun tightening security.

Norway is deploying its military to protect oil and gas installations, while Finland’s border guard upped its monitoring of maritime traffic and infrastructure. Denmark also moved to boost protections around energy sites.

And although many governments have formally declined to point fingers, NATO sent a thinly veiled warning to the Kremlin on Thursday that it would respond to an attack on allies’ key infrastructure.

“All currently available information indicates that this is the result of deliberate, reckless, and irresponsible acts of sabotage,” NATO’s principal political decision-making body, the North Atlantic Council, said in a statement.

The group said it had committed “to prepare for, deter and defend against the coercive use of energy and other hybrid tactics by state and non-state actors.” And it sent a warning: “Any deliberate attack against Allies’ critical infrastructure would be met with a united and determined response.”

Nevertheless, the gas leaks present a thorny challenge for the alliance, which has pledged to protect every inch of allies’ territory.

Hybrid attacks are often designed to hit adversaries without necessarily triggering a full-scale conflict or revealing with certainty the perpetrators’ identity. Is a cyberattack on a privately run dam always the military’s responsibility? Can investigators ever convince the public that Russia was behind a rural explosion?

“The Russian military and the Kremlin love those debates — was it them, was it not them — and this kind of plausible deniability," said Rod Thornton, a senior lecturer at King's College London. “They want to encourage debate or disagreement within NATO about how to react.”

And when NATO isn’t technically at war with Russia, it becomes even more quixotic.

“It's complicated stuff for NATO to handle because it is not peacetime, but it's not war in the sense that it necessarily triggers Article Five,” said Kristian Søby Kristensen, a senior researcher at the University of Copenhagen’s Center for Military Studies, referencing NATO’s founding principle that an attack on one member is an attack on all members.

Experts point out that the location of the leaks complicates possible responses — pulling in multiple countries and companies with subsidiaries in even more countries.

“This is precisely an act of sabotage that creates uncertainty,” Kristensen said.

“It’s difficult to figure out what this actually is,” he said. “Is it a standalone? Is it just the first instance of a longer campaign? Who are the ones responsible for responding? What should the response be? Who has responsibility for cleaning up?”

At the same time, NATO’s ability to completely block Russia from attacking infrastructure is limited.

“You cannot put guards on every kilometer of undersea cable,” said Charly Salonius-Pasternak, the leading researcher at the Finnish Institute of International Affairs.

“So the question becomes,” he added, “can you deter this?”

The same is true of nearly any critical infrastructure. The energy grid is disparate and often rural. The financial system is spread across a network of private companies.

One approach, according to Salonius-Pasternak, is to make sure key infrastructure “is so robust, that while it would be inconvenient, it doesn't matter” if one piece is sabotaged.

Allies can also choose to be more visible and “increase presence, either in the air or the sea,” he said, in order to “show national populations as well as Russia that we're doing something.”

Another option, Salonius-Pasternak added, is “very aggressive patrolling” — which could involve aerial surveillance, sensors and boarding ships. This approach “takes a massive amount of resources,” but the high cost also makes it a “much more credible” signal.

And while the public’s attention may be focused on Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and rising prices, risks to undersea infrastructure have been on policymakers’ minds for some time.

Early this year, British chief of defense staff Admiral Sir Tony Radakin warned about an increase in Russia’s underwater activity, telling The Times that “Russia has grown the capability to put at threat those undersea cables and potentially exploit those undersea cables.”

Now, some experts say Russia’s battleground losses could fuel more use of hybrid tactics against Western adversaries.


Back in Brussels


In Brussels, officials acknowledge that there is a need to improve how assets are secured.

“We need to strengthen protection of critical infrastructure as quickly as possible,” said a second senior diplomat from an eastern NATO country. “It will be ensured,” the diplomat said, adding: “There are many objects of concern.”

The University of Copenhagen’s Kristensen said a response could involve more NATO planning for future crisis management procedures, paying more attention to the gray zone and critical infrastructure, and focusing NATO allies’ military assets “on conducting surveillance and ensuring your situational awareness.”

Hanno Pevkur, Estonia’s minister of defense, has urged allies to learn from the experience of war.

“What we can see from the Russian war against Ukraine is that critical infrastructure of all kinds is a valuable target for the aggressor — from roads to bridges, to hospitals, to supply lines of all kinds,” the minister said in a text message.

“That is why,” he said, “every country of NATO has to keep a close eye on the learning moments from this war, so all critical infrastructure that needs protection is definitely under our heightened attention.”

Inevitably, boosting such defenses is always a work in progress.

“We have done some work,” said the first senior diplomat. “We are not starting from scratch.”

AI Disclaimer: An advanced artificial intelligence (AI) system generated the content of this page on its own. This innovative technology conducts extensive research from a variety of reliable sources, performs rigorous fact-checking and verification, cleans up and balances biased or manipulated content, and presents a minimal factual summary that is just enough yet essential for you to function as an informed and educated citizen. Please keep in mind, however, that this system is an evolving technology, and as a result, the article may contain accidental inaccuracies or errors. We urge you to help us improve our site by reporting any inaccuracies you find using the "Contact Us" link at the bottom of this page. Your helpful feedback helps us improve our system and deliver more precise content. When you find an article of interest here, please look for the full and extensive coverage of this topic in traditional news sources, as they are written by professional journalists that we try to support, not replace. We appreciate your understanding and assistance.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
16 Billion Login Credentials Leaked in Unprecedented Cybersecurity Breach
Senate hearing on who was 'really running' Biden White House kicks off
Hungary Ranked Among the World’s Safest Travel Destinations for 2025
G7 Leaders Fail to Reach Consensus on Key Global Issues
FBI and Senate Investigate Allegations of Chinese Plot to Influence the 2020 Election in Biden’s Favor Using Fake U.S. Driver’s Licenses
Trump Demands Iran's Unconditional Surrender Amid Escalating Conflict
Shock Within Iran’s Leadership: Khamenei’s Failed Plan to Launch 1,000 Missiles Against Israel
Wreck of $17 Billion San José Galleon Identified Off Colombia After 300 Years
Man Convicted of Fraud After Booking Over 120 Free Flights Posing as Flight Attendant
Iran Launches Extensive Missile Attack on Israel Following Israeli Strikes on Nuclear Sites
Beata Thunberg Rebrands as Beata Ernman Amidst Sister's Activism Controversy
Hungarian Parliament Approves Citizenship Suspension Law
Prime Minister Orbán Criticizes EU's Ukraine Accession Plans
Hungarian Delicacies Introduced to Japanese Market
Hungary's Industrial Output Rises Amid Battery Sector Slump
President Sulyok Celebrates 15 Years of Hungarian Unity Efforts
Hungary's Szeleczki Shines at World Judo Championships
Visegrád Construction Trends Diverge as Hungary Lags
Hungary Hosts National Quantum Technology Workshop
Hungarian Animation Featured at Annecy Festival
Israel Issues Ultimatum to Iran Over Potential Retaliation and Nuclear Facilities
UK and EU Reach New Economic Agreement
Coinbase CEO Warns Bitcoin Could Supplant US Dollar Amid Mounting National Debt
Trump to Iran: Make a Deal — Sign or Die
Operation "Like a Lion": Israel Strikes Iran in Unprecedented Offensive
Israel Launches 'Operation Rising Lion' Targeting Iranian Nuclear and Military Sites
UK and EU Reach Agreement on Gibraltar's Schengen Integration
Israeli Finance Minister Imposes Banking Penalties on Palestinians
U.S. Inflation Rises to 2.4% in May Amid Trade Tensions
Trump's Policies Prompt Decline in Chinese Student Enrollment in U.S.
Global Oceans Near Record Temperatures as CO₂ Levels Climb
Trump Announces U.S.-China Trade Deal Covering Rare Earths
Smuggled U.S. Fuel Funds Mexican Cartels Amid Crackdown
Austrian School Shooting Leaves Nine Dead in Graz
Bezos's Lavish Venice Wedding Sparks Local Protests
Europe Prepares for Historic Lunar Rover Landing
Italian Parents Seek Therapy Amid Lengthy School Holidays
British Fishing Vessel Seized by France Fined €30,000
Dutch Government Collapses Amid Migration Policy Dispute
UK Commits to 3.5% GDP Defence Spending Under NATO Pressure
Germany Moves to Expedite Migrant Deportations
US Urges UK to Raise Defence Spending to 5% of GDP
Israeli Forces Intercept Gaza-Bound Aid Vessel Carrying Greta Thunberg
IMF Warns of Severe Global Trade War Impacts on Emerging Markets
Low Turnout Jeopardizes Italy's Citizenship Reform Referendum
Transatlantic Interest Rate Divergence Widens as Trump Pressures Powell
EU Lawmaker Calls for Broader Exemptions in Supply Chain Legislation
France's Defense Spending Plans Threatened by High National Debt
European Small-Cap Stocks Outperform U.S. Rivals Amid Growth Revival
Switzerland Proposes $26 Billion Capital Increase for UBS
×